Hire A Social Catfish Search Specialist. Let's Get To The Bottom Of It Now! Hire A Social Catfish Search Specialist. Let's Get To The Bottom Of It Now!

Tanya; <mysoulangel1@evolaok.com/Valentinajuice@outlook.com/DiAna-Var1988@outlook.com>

Scammers from Russia, Ukraine, or any other former Soviet Union countries.
Post Reply
User avatar
IceFM
Moderator
Posts: 100113
Joined: Fri Nov 16, 2007 10:06 am
Location: .... on the Baltic Beach

Karligash; <Karlygash8705@outlook.com>

Post by IceFM »

.... from 419-Spam with the same Pic

Salute..!
Dear the stranger, I wish to be assured, as it is strong you wish to find and to meet with new and class the girl?
My name Karlygash. I hope, that to you my photo,.,
I wish to meet someone with whom my life will be counterbalanced and surprising.,
I very much interesting, opened and positive the girl.!
But I one now and I very much have got tired from it,!.
So I have addressed in marriage agency and have written to you the letter!,,
Actually, I in searches adequate the man for serious relations and a combination marriage in the future.!
My purpose - to meet love.,,
I very much hope, that you this man.,!
I will be glad if we find our common interests, and our acquaintance - the most significant moment in our future life,!,
Now I do not know, as is strong have interest in continuation our conversation, therefore I am more than information on I will write about myself in the following letter.!,
With impatience I wait your letter with big impatience,.
With the best regards, Karlygash!,


Received: from uiqp (unknown [77.40.62.153])
Reply-To: Karlygash <Karlygash8705@outlook.com>
From: Karlygash <v17a27@pmg.gy.svitavy.cz>
Date: Wed, 18 May 2022 08:41:54 +0300
Organization: Daalder Kenzie


MARI-VOLGATELECOM
xDSL dynamic pools
Vasiliy Golovin
VolgaTelecom Mari El branch
Sovetskaya 138
424000 Yoshkar-Ola
Russia
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
+++ Я не воюю с Россией +++
+++ The FAQ / FAQ in deutsch +++

According to research, around 10% of the profiles on Match are fake.

How To Outsmart a Romance Scammer

Check Out Our Top10 Social Catfish Photos of the Week

You can find someone on all social media platforms at once through a reverse search.

The Fastest Way To Silence The Doubts If You're Being Catfished

How to Know If A Video Call Was Faked, Or if The Person Behind it Is Real

User avatar
IceFM
Moderator
Posts: 100113
Joined: Fri Nov 16, 2007 10:06 am
Location: .... on the Baltic Beach

Karligash; <Karlygash8705@outlook.com>

Post by IceFM »

... from 419-Spam

Good evening..!
Lovely the stranger, I wish to look, as you are interested in searches and to meet with new and class the girl?
My name is Karlygash. I think, that to you my photo,.,
I in searches the man with whom my life will be quiet and interesting,!.
I very much interesting, opened and positive the girl,.,
But to me am lonely at present and I very much have got tired from it.!,
So I have gone in agency of acquaintances and have written to you the letter,.
Actually, I search adequate the man for stable relations and marriage further,,
Dream of all my life - to find love!!
I very much hope, that you this man,.
I will be glad if we find our common interests, and our meeting - the most great moment in our future!,,
At present I do not know, as is strong have interest in continuation our correspondence, for this reason in more details I will write about myself in the following letter..
With impatience I wait your answer with huge impatience,!
All kind, Karlygash,.,


Received: from aeeylv (unknown [77.40.62.153])
Reply-To: Karlygosh <Karlygash8705@outlook.com>
From: Karlygosh <v17a27@pmg.gy.svitavy.cz>
Date: Wed, 18 May 2022 00:24:28 +0300
Organization: Tonje Snaselova


MARI-VOLGATELECOM
xDSL dynamic pools
Vasiliy Golovin
VolgaTelecom Mari El branch
Sovetskaya 138
424000 Yoshkar-Ola
Russia


3wgdj.jpg
Image
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
+++ Я не воюю с Россией +++
+++ The FAQ / FAQ in deutsch +++
User avatar
IceFM
Moderator
Posts: 100113
Joined: Fri Nov 16, 2007 10:06 am
Location: .... on the Baltic Beach

Karlygash; <abildakarlygash@outlook.com>

Post by IceFM »

..... from DMF-Spam

Kind time of days,.
Lovely the stranger, I wish to look, as you are interested in searches and to begin acquaintance with new and lovely the woman?
My name is Karlygash. I hope, that I to you is pleasant is nice,,
I in searches someone with whom my life will be counterbalanced and interesting,.!
I very much cheerful, kind and positive the girl.!,
But I one now and I very much have got tired from it!..
Therefore I have gone in agency of acquaintances and have written to you the letter!.
Actually, I search adequate the man for serious relations and a combination marriage further..
My purpose - to meet the beloved of all my life.,!
I wish to believe, that you this man!,,
I will be glad if we find one goal in life, and our meeting - the most important moment in our future.
Now I do not know, as is strong you you are interested in continuation our correspondence, for this reason in more details I will tell about myself later..,
With impatience I wait for the reciprocal letter with big impatience!,
Good pastime, Karlygash,!,


Received: from mhbocnj (unknown [77.40.62.153])
Reply-To: Karlygash <abildakarlygash@outlook.com>
From: Karlygash <v17a27@pmg.gy.svitavy.cz>
Date: Wed, 18 May 2022 19:30:21 +0300
Organization: Krommenhoek Marjorie


MARI-VOLGATELECOM
xDSL dynamic pools
Vasiliy Golovin
VolgaTelecom Mari El branch
Sovetskaya 138
424000 Yoshkar-Ola
Russia


3wrgd
Image
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
+++ Я не воюю с Россией +++
+++ The FAQ / FAQ in deutsch +++
User avatar
IceFM
Moderator
Posts: 100113
Joined: Fri Nov 16, 2007 10:06 am
Location: .... on the Baltic Beach

Karligash; <abildakarlygash@outlook.com>

Post by IceFM »

.... from DLB-Spam

Hello.
Lovely the stranger, I wish to be assured, how much you wish to find and to begin acquaintance with new and remarkable the girl?
My name Karlygash. I wish to believe, that to you my photo..,
I search the person with whom my life will be balanced and fascinating..!
I very much interesting, kind and positive the girl,.,
But I still one and I very much have got tired from such life!,
Therefore I have addressed in marriage agency and have sent to you the letter.!
Actually, I wish to meet present the man for stable relations and marriages in the future,,.
Dream of all my life - to meet love,.!
I wish to believe, that you this man..,
I will be glad if we find common language, and our acquaintance - the most important moment in beginning of our relationship,!.
Now I do not know, how much you you are interested in continuation our correspondence, therefore I am more than information on I will let know about myself in the following letter!,
I will wait for the reciprocal letter with huge impatience,!
Good pastime, Karlygash,!


Received: from dmht (unknown [77.40.62.153])
Reply-To: Karligash <abildakarlygash@outlook.com>
From: Karligash <v17a27@pmg.gy.svitavy.cz>
Date: Wed, 18 May 2022 19:46:33 +0300
Organization: Russel


MARI-VOLGATELECOM
xDSL dynamic pools
Vasiliy Golovin
VolgaTelecom Mari El branch
Sovetskaya 138
424000 Yoshkar-Ola
Russia
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
+++ Я не воюю с Россией +++
+++ The FAQ / FAQ in deutsch +++
User avatar
IceFM
Moderator
Posts: 100113
Joined: Fri Nov 16, 2007 10:06 am
Location: .... on the Baltic Beach

Karlygosh; <KarlygashKZ87@outlook.com>

Post by IceFM »

..... from 419-Spam

Good day,.!
Lovely the stranger, I wish the nobility, as you wish to find and to begin acquaintance with new and lovely the girl?
My name is Karlygash. I think, that you from me in delight,
I in searches the man with whom my life will be quiet and interesting,,,
I very much interesting, kind and positive the girl!!
But I still one and I very much have got tired from this vital situation.,
Therefore I have gone in agency of acquaintances and have sent to you the letter!..
Actually, I wish to meet serious the man for serious relations and a combination marriage in the future,,
My purpose - to find love.!,
I very much hope, that you this man..!
I will be glad if we find one goal in life, and our acquaintance - the most important moment in beginning of our relationship!,,
At present I do not know, how much you you are interested in continuation our conversation, therefore I am more than information on I will let know about myself in the following letter!
I will wait your answer with huge impatience,!,
Kiss, Karlygash,,


Received: from [77.40.62.153] (port=14193 helo=ypnwcd) by server.kanalben.com with esmtpsa
(TLS1.2) tls TLS_ECDHE_RSA_WITH_AES_256_GCM_SHA384 (Exim 4.95)
Reply-To: Karlygosh <KarlygashKZ87@outlook.com>
From: Karlygosh <info@kanalben.com>
Date: Thu, 19 May 2022 01:11:13 +0300
Organization: Catena


MARI-VOLGATELECOM
xDSL dynamic pools
Vasiliy Golovin
VolgaTelecom Mari El branch
Sovetskaya 138
424000 Yoshkar-Ola
Russia


svbhss.png
Image
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
+++ Я не воюю с Россией +++
+++ The FAQ / FAQ in deutsch +++
User avatar
IceFM
Moderator
Posts: 100113
Joined: Fri Nov 16, 2007 10:06 am
Location: .... on the Baltic Beach

Karlygosh; <KarlygashKZ87@outlook.com>

Post by IceFM »

..... from 419-Spam

Hi!.
Lovely the stranger, I wish the nobility, as it is strong you wish to find and to meet with new and remarkable the girl?
My name Karlygash. I wish to believe, that I to you like on a photo!..
I wish to meet someone with whom my life will be quiet and surprising!!
I very much interesting, opened and positive the girl,,!
But I still one and I very much have got tired from this vital situation,.!
Therefore I have addressed in marriage agency and have written to you the letter.!,
Actually, I search adequate the man for serious relations and a combination marriage in the future.,
My purpose - to meet the beloved of all my life.,.
I very much hope, that you this man.,!
I will be glad if we find our common interests, and our acquaintance - the most significant moment in our future life.
Now I do not know, as is strong have interest in continuation our conversation, for this reason in more details I will tell about myself later,.,
With impatience I wait for the reciprocal letter with big impatience,!
All kind, Karlygash,..


Received: from ueeyi (unknown [77.40.62.153])
Reply-To: Karligash <KarlygashKZ87@outlook.com>
From: Karligash <v17a27@pmg.gy.svitavy.cz>
Date: Wed, 18 May 2022 22:49:20 +0300
Organization: Brevik


MARI-VOLGATELECOM
xDSL dynamic pools
Vasiliy Golovin
VolgaTelecom Mari El branch
Sovetskaya 138
424000 Yoshkar-Ola
Russia
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
+++ Я не воюю с Россией +++
+++ The FAQ / FAQ in deutsch +++
User avatar
IceFM
Moderator
Posts: 100113
Joined: Fri Nov 16, 2007 10:06 am
Location: .... on the Baltic Beach

Natalia; <Natalia.Solntse@outlook.com>

Post by IceFM »

..... next Idiot is back .... DLB-Spam

My dear friend. I am was lucky enough to write to you, please excuse me beforehand if I'm had bothered you. Well,as a matter of fact, I am tired of my lonely and agreed to try out Net internet dating site! I rely on that this action will be another page in my future whole life. So,I'm will tell a little story about me for you for know me better! I hope, that the written exchanges between us will proceed, and you are wondered and read my email. I don't really know where to begin my description. I'm never tried to write to someone my person in the mail before this moment. I am can describe my character as the emotional, energetic, outspoken person. I am a extraverted person though at the same time I'm a self-confident, person. I have normally like heartiness straightforward and frankness. I hope you are interested, that our letters will not interrupt. In the next e-mail, I would like to know more about you, your way of life. I'm sending you my personal images. I want that you like it, and we can get closer to each other. Goodbye, Natalia.


Received: from out10.wanadoo.es (out10.wanadoo.es. [62.36.20.210])
Date: Sun, 7 Aug 2022 07:31:37 -0700
From: Natalia Princess <miguel.oscar@wanadoo.es>
Reply-To: Natalia.Solntse@outlook.com
To: j.miguel.u@hotmail.com


UNI2-NET
Addresses IP for corporate ABI clients
France Telecom España
Hostmaster Administrator FTE
Parque Empresarial La Finca
Edificio 9
Paseo del Club Deportivo, 1
28223 Pozuelo de Alarcon
Madrid, Spain


PIC-00716.jpg
Image
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
+++ Я не воюю с Россией +++
+++ The FAQ / FAQ in deutsch +++
User avatar
IceFM
Moderator
Posts: 100113
Joined: Fri Nov 16, 2007 10:06 am
Location: .... on the Baltic Beach

Natalia; <Natalia.Solntse@outlook.com>

Post by IceFM »

..... from 2nd. DLB-Spam

Hello. I am was lucky enough to write to u, excuse me previously if I'm had bothered you. Well,as a matter of fact, I am tired of being alone and agreed to try Internet dating web site! I expect that this will be another
stage in my future life. So,to know me better I'm will write u a little bit about me! I want, that the written exchanges between us will proceed, and you're interested and open my e-mail. I don't sure where to start my description.
I'm never attempt to write to somebody my person in the mail before this moment. I am can describe my character as the emotional, active, outspoken girl. I'm a considerate person though at the same time I am a proud, person. I have normally appreciated heartiness outspoken and frankness. I hope you are interested, that our letters will not interrupt. In a future letter, I want to read more about u, your way of life. I'm sending u my personal images. I hope that you like it, and we can get acquainted more. Yours sincerely, Natalia.


Received: from [109.196.79.131] (helo=5hOu7G.justright) by out10.wanadoo.es with esmtpa (Exim 4.68)
Date: Sun, 7 Aug 2022 13:13:26 -0200
From: Nata Snowflake <jd.diaz@wanadoo.es>
Reply-To: Natalia.Solntse@outlook.com
To: edgardo.alarconl@gmail.com


TRYTECH-NET
Trytech Ltd.
Trytek NOC
Alexandrov Oktabrskaya st. 8
Aleksandrov City
Vladimirskaya obl.
Russia, 601650


PIC-52351.jpg
Image
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
+++ Я не воюю с Россией +++
+++ The FAQ / FAQ in deutsch +++
User avatar
IceFM
Moderator
Posts: 100113
Joined: Fri Nov 16, 2007 10:06 am
Location: .... on the Baltic Beach

Svetlana; <SvetaComet@hotmail.com>

Post by IceFM »

..... from 2nd. DLB-Spam

Salutti dear friend!.
great day and great mood!.
I seek a friendly man to establish a very strong relationship.,
I are alone and I am very sad to spend my evenings alone..
I decided send you a letter maybe we can get closer, I can send you picture , give information about me!.
I locate in the Kazakhstan.
My name Svetlana,. I am 35 years!. My birthday May 28, According to the horoscope I am gemini,.
If you are interested in our further acquaintance then I am very happy about our communication!.
Attach me your images and I will attach my photos too.!
Wonderful day,. Best wishes, Svetlana.


.... no IP traceable
Reply-To: Svetliana <SvetaComet@hotmail.com>
From: Svetliana <wander.pezzin@acad.ftec.com.br>
Date: Sat, 7 Oct 2023 13:35:29 +0200
To: Undisclosed recipients:;


I3-P3-N11-RRB.jpg
Image
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
+++ Я не воюю с Россией +++
+++ The FAQ / FAQ in deutsch +++
User avatar
IceFM
Moderator
Posts: 100113
Joined: Fri Nov 16, 2007 10:06 am
Location: .... on the Baltic Beach

Svetlana; <SvetaComet@hotmail.com>

Post by IceFM »

Hello xxxxxxx,

Dear xxxxxx, thanks you for your letter. I am glad to that you have written
to me. I shall hope that in the future, we shall be very good friends, and can
and more. I do not know what to tell in my first letter because I never got
acquainted through the Internet before. It - something new and unusual to me.
But I shall try, write good letters to you. Please not be too strict to My
mistakes in words, the English language - not my native language. But I Assume,
that I know it well.

Well, my name is Svetlana. My friends call me Sveta. as you know. You can call
me How do you like. I won't be disappointed. I am 35 years old. My birthday is
28. - May 1988. My height is 169 cm. My weight is 59 kg. You can see my photo,
it do you like it? I live in the city of Pavlodar. Pavlodar is a famous city in
Kazakhstan. Pavlodar is a very beautiful city. I graduated from medical
university. My Education will consist of 3 levels: school, college, university.
You know anything about this city? This is a small city, home to almost 160,000
people. About 500 kilometers from the capital of Kazakhstan. Do you know the
city Astana? Tell me what is your full name? Where were you born and in what
city live? When is your birthday? Who are you according to your zodiac sign? I
studied for 18 years. For 18 years I also studied English. I finished university
at 25 years old. How I was awarded a medal for excellent results during my
studies my studies. Then I worked with the main therapist in a small clinic for
4 years. It was very interesting and at the same time responsible. I was happy
give health to people, help them. Much depends on me during actions. You think,
what kind of a good dream is this? I guess I'm a Doctor, I'll work in the
Clinic, as a pediatric therapist. I treat children.

You can see my photo, do you like it? I don't have a man right now and I
completely alone and free for relationships. I was searching on the Internet as
a result, I was disappointed in the men of our city. Here's some good stuff
people, they are all tough and do not know how to love. I have a small house
with small garden. I live alone, so I don’t know how to garden. it's constant.
But nevertheless, my garden is very beautiful and pleasant. I like grow flowers
because they are the most beautiful things created nature. I live alone, I have
neither children nor a boyfriend. Sometimes I I feel very lonely in my house.
Perhaps for this reason I decided get to know you. I'm already 35, and I
approach life philosophically. I I have a home, a job, friends, but I can’t say
that I’m happy. I did not have I can give many gifts to my better half. I wrote
to you again, this means that I can share my thoughts and feelings with you. I
hope you will there will be no laughter. And we will write each other many
letters. I am very I'm glad and grateful that you answered my letter because I
decided to try meet people online only once. I've never met before in this case.
I can't fully understand how this works because I don't have computer. I'm just
new to the Internet.
:mrgreen: :mrgreen: :party: But I hope that I will able to write to you constantly. I
hope you are interested in our communication like me. You can tell me anything
you want. I will glad to know everything about your life. This is just a woman's
curiosity. I understand it Tastes vary, but I hope you like my image. But I must
tell me I can't get large files. I will have problems. Since I use computer in
the cafe. I hope that there will be no more letters from you. There will be more
than 5.5 megabytes, we have a very expensive Internet. If not, I'll understand
and won't be angry. I will be waiting for your letters with your photographs. Be
sure to send me some photos, I want to show you a little bit. I hope, that you
will write to me soon. Thank you in advance. Best wishes.

P.S. As I will wait your photos! I very much wish to see you on a photo because
I consider it to see important each other on a photo!

Sveta


..... no IP traceable
Date: Tue, 10 Oct 2023 20:49:21 +0300
From: Sveta <SvetaComet@hotmail.com>


IMG-15-02-18.jpg
Image

IMG-3-05-19.jpg
Image
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
+++ Я не воюю с Россией +++
+++ The FAQ / FAQ in deutsch +++
User avatar
IceFM
Moderator
Posts: 100113
Joined: Fri Nov 16, 2007 10:06 am
Location: .... on the Baltic Beach

Svetlana; <SvetaComet@hotmail.com>

Post by IceFM »

..... unasked answer

Hello xxxxxxx.

I already sent you a letter. But you still have not answered me. Why? Do you not
want to talk to me? You didn’t like my photo? Did you have time to answer? I
don’t know ... I’m not sure that you got my previous one, so I decided to write
to you again in the hope of receiving your answer...

Sveta



..... no IP traceable
Date: Mon, 16 Oct 2023 09:22:36 +0300
From: Sveta <SvetaComet@hotmail.com>


IMG-3-05-19.jpg
Image
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
+++ Я не воюю с Россией +++
+++ The FAQ / FAQ in deutsch +++
User avatar
IceFM
Moderator
Posts: 100113
Joined: Fri Nov 16, 2007 10:06 am
Location: .... on the Baltic Beach

Diana; <DiAna-Var1988@outlook.com>

Post by IceFM »

..... from DLB-Spam.

Hello!
great day and happy mood.
I want a good man to establish a very reliable relationship.
I live alone and I am very lonely.
I decided send you a letter maybe we can make friends, I can attach you picture, tell about me.
I live in the Georgia.
My name Diana. I am 36 years old.
My birthday May 28.
According to the horoscope I am - gemini.
If you have nothing against an acquaintance then I am very happy about our communication.
Send me your photos and I will send my photos too.
Wonderful day!
Best wishes, Diana.


….. no IP traceble
Reply-To: Di <DiAna-Var1988@outlook.com>
From: Di <sitedgspe_slp@sspslp.gob.mx>
Date: Tue, 12 Nov 2024 08:06:00 +0100
To: Undisclosed recipients:;


Z9-SVA2-QAA2.jpg
Image
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
+++ Я не воюю с Россией +++
+++ The FAQ / FAQ in deutsch +++
User avatar
IceFM
Moderator
Posts: 100113
Joined: Fri Nov 16, 2007 10:06 am
Location: .... on the Baltic Beach

Diana; <diana_gruz@outlook.com>

Post by IceFM »

.... with the same pic in 419-Spam.

Good day!
great day and happy mood.
I seek a decent man to establish a very strong relationship.
I are alone and I am very lonely.
I thought write you maybe we can make friends, I can send you picture, tell about me.
I live in the center of Eastern Europe and Near Asia-Georgia. I Diana. I am thirty-five years old.
My birthday May twenty eight. According to the horoscope I am - gemini.
If you share my desire to meet then I am very happy about communication with you.
Attach me your photos and I will attach my photos too.
Wonderful day! All the best, Diana.


….. no IP traceble
Reply-To: Dianka <diana_gruz@outlook.com>
From: Dianka <jordi_jacobo@usmp.pe>
Date: Tue, 12 Nov 2024 09:05:44 +0100
To: Undisclosed recipients:;
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
+++ Я не воюю с Россией +++
+++ The FAQ / FAQ in deutsch +++
User avatar
IceFM
Moderator
Posts: 100113
Joined: Fri Nov 16, 2007 10:06 am
Location: .... on the Baltic Beach

Diana; <diana.vart28@outlook.com>

Post by IceFM »

.... from E-Spam.

Nice to meet you!
great day and happy mood.
I seek a friendly man to establish a very strong relationship.
I live alone and I am very lonely.
I decided write you maybe we can become friends and more, I can attach you picture, give information about me.
I live in the Georgia.
My name Diana. I am thirty-five years old.
My birthday May twenty eight.
According to the horoscope I am - gemini.
If you share my desire to meet then I am very happy about communication with you.
Attach me your photos and I will attach my photos too.
Positive day! Best regards, Diana.


…. no IP traceable
Reply-To: Didi <diana.vart28@outlook.com>
From: Didi <leogonmu@exatec.tec.mx>
Date: Wed, 13 Nov 2024 08:34:49 +0100
To: Undisclosed recipients:;


2-NF8-MFUOAV.jpg
Image
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
+++ Я не воюю с Россией +++
+++ The FAQ / FAQ in deutsch +++
User avatar
IceFM
Moderator
Posts: 100113
Joined: Fri Nov 16, 2007 10:06 am
Location: .... on the Baltic Beach

Diana; <DiAna-Var1988@outlook.com>

Post by IceFM »

.... with the first pic in DLB-Spam.

Greetings my new friend!
great day and wonderful mood.
I seek a handsome man to establish a very strong relationship.
I live alone and I am very sad to spend my evenings alone.
I thought send you a letter maybe we can become friends and more, I can send you picture, give information about me.
I locate in the center of Eastern Europe and Near Asia-Georgia.
I Diana. I am 36 years old.
I was born May twenty eight.
My zodiac sign - gemini.
If you have nothing against an acquaintance then I am very happy about our communication.
Send me your images and I will send my images too.
Good day!
Best regards, Diana.


…. no IP traceable
Reply-To: Dina <DiAna-Var1988@outlook.com>
From: Dina <matias.abarcam@utem.cl>
Date: Wed, 13 Nov 2024 08:05:45 +0100
To: Undisclosed recipients:;
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
+++ Я не воюю с Россией +++
+++ The FAQ / FAQ in deutsch +++
Post Reply